Metal music has been around for decades, and its passionate fanbase values knowledge, dedication, and appreciation for the genre. Some people claim to be metal fans but only scratch the surface. If you notice these signs, they might not be as into metal as they say.
1. They Only Know One Metallica Song
Metallica is one of the biggest metal bands of all time with classics like ‘Master of Puppets,’ ‘Fade to Black,’ and ‘One.’ However, some people only recognize ‘Nothing Else Matters’ — a song that even non-metal fans hear often. If someone calls themselves a Metallica fan but can’t name another song, their knowledge of the band is probably limited.
2. Their “Metal” Taste Is Just Linkin Park and Evanescence

Linkin Park and Evanescence made great rock and alternative music, but they are not considered full-fledged metal bands. If someone says they listen to metal but only mentions these two, they might not be exploring the heavier side of the genre. Bands like Iron Maiden, Slayer, or Pantera rarely show up in their playlists.
3. Their Playlist Only Has Popular Rock Hits

A real metal fan usually has a variety of bands and songs in their library. If someone’s only playlist is full of the most mainstream rock songs, it possibly means they haven’t really explored the genre. Songs like ‘Sweet Child O’ Mine,’ ‘Livin’ on a Prayer,’ or ‘Eye of the Tiger’ may be iconic, but they don’t represent the full spectrum of metal.
4. They Only Sing Along to the Big Hits at Concerts

Metal fans enjoy the entire setlist at live shows, even the lesser-known tracks. Someone who only gets excited when the most famous songs start playing but looks bored during the rest of the show might not be as into metal as they claim. True fans appreciate the deep cuts just as much as the hits.
5. They Wear Band T-Shirts Without Knowing the Band

Band t-shirts are a fashion trend, but a real metal fan knows the music behind the logos. If someone wears a Slayer, Black Sabbath, or Megadeth shirt but can’t name an album or song from the band, they might just be following a trend rather than actually being into metal.