Bullet For My Valentine’s ‘Temper Temper’ is one of the most divisive releases in the band’s discography. The album received mixed reviews ever since it came out in 2013. Many factors played into the negative reviews, but did the record actually deserve the hate?
The Critical Divide
‘Temper Temper’ represents a significant period of experimentation for Bullet For My Valentine. Source Magazine notes that songs like ‘P.O.W.’ and ‘Dirty Little Secrets’ showcase new territories. ‘P.O.W.’ draws comparisons to LostProphets while ‘Dirty Little Secrets’ ventures into emo-pop territory.
This divides critics and fans on the album’s quality. The Guardian cites the “cynicism and a lack of dirt under its nails” as major drawbacks, for example. Meanwhile, ARTISTdirect awards it a perfect five-star rating, praising its fusion of “tight, technical thrash with the biggest hooks of their career.”
Fans generally don’t pay much mind to the record though some don’t hesitate to declare it as the worst in their discography. The band members themselves acknowledge that ‘Temper Temper’ isn’t their strongest work. But this doesn’t mean the album doesn’t have redeeming qualities.
Album Structure And Composition
Loudwire’s review highlights the album’s strengths and particularly praises its mid-section. The title track earns recognition for its “speedy guitar work and Michael ‘Moose’ Thomas’ cymbal-heavy drumbeats.”
The album’s title reflects the internal dynamics within the band during its creation. The group channels their conflicts into the creative process. They use these tensions as fuel for their musical expression, resulting in an occasionally agressive sound. The review notes that the pacing effectively mirrors the emotional buildup of anger.
The album’s composition shows careful attention to pacing and energy levels. The closing track, ‘Livin’ Life (On the Edge of a Knife),’ emerges as one of the more energetic pieces. It provides a powerful conclusion to the album. This strategic track placement demonstrates thoughtful consideration of the overall listening experience.
So, despite the criticism, the album deserves more than simple dismissal or acclaim.
